Band 9 model answer
Few dilemmas are as pressing as the apparent conflict between economic prosperity and the health of the planet. While growth brings tangible benefits, I believe environmental protection must take precedence, because prosperity is meaningless on a degraded planet.
Supporters of prioritising development argue that economic growth underpins human welfare. Expanding industry creates jobs, lifts populations out of poverty and generates the tax revenue needed to fund schools, hospitals and, indeed, environmental programmes themselves. From this perspective, developing nations in particular cannot be expected to forgo industrialisation when their citizens still lack basic necessities.
However, the opposing view is, to my mind, more far-sighted. Unrestrained growth that exhausts natural resources and destabilises the climate ultimately undermines the very prosperity it seeks to create. Rising sea levels, crop failures and extreme weather impose colossal economic costs, often falling hardest on the poorest. Treating the environment as expendable is therefore not only ethically questionable but economically short-sighted.
In my opinion, growth and conservation need not be irreconcilable. The concept of sustainable development shows that economies can expand through green technology, renewable energy and the circular use of resources without plundering the natural world. The goal should be prosperity that endures, not prosperity that consumes its own foundations.
In conclusion, although economic development is undeniably important, it cannot be pursued at the expense of the environment on which all life depends. Governments should embrace sustainable models that reconcile growth with long-term ecological stability.
Examiner’s notes
- Both sides are given genuine weight before a principled opinion is argued, satisfying the discussion question fully.
- The essay introduces a resolving concept ('sustainable development') rather than simply siding with one view, showing sophistication.
- Lexis is precise and ambitious: underpins, far-sighted, expendable, circular use of resources.