Parenting & Children

Only Child vs Having Siblings

The question
Some people believe that being an only child has a negative effect on a person's development, while others think children without siblings grow up just as well-rounded. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 9 model answer

With family sizes shrinking in many countries, debate has grown over whether children raised without siblings are disadvantaged. Some maintain that only children miss vital lessons, whereas others insist they develop just as fully. In my view, an only child can thrive, since upbringing matters far more than the presence of siblings.

Those who view only children negatively point to the social skills siblings supposedly cultivate. Growing up with brothers and sisters, it is argued, teaches children to share, negotiate, and tolerate conflict from an early age. Only children, by contrast, may receive undivided attention and rarely have to compete for resources, which some fear breeds selfishness or difficulty cooperating with peers. The constant companionship of siblings, supporters add, also guards against loneliness.

On the other side, many contend that only children are no less well-adjusted. Freed from rivalry, they often enjoy closer relationships with their parents and benefit from concentrated emotional and financial investment. Far from being isolated, most form strong friendships at school and through activities, acquiring the very social skills siblings are credited with teaching. Indeed, only children frequently display maturity and self-reliance precisely because they spend time among adults.

Having weighed both arguments, I am convinced that the number of siblings is not decisive. What truly shapes a child is the quality of parenting and the breadth of social opportunities provided. An only child whose parents encourage friendships and shared activities can be every bit as generous and capable as one with several siblings, while a poorly raised child may struggle regardless of family size. Character, ultimately, is forged by experience and guidance, not by birth order alone.

Examiner’s notes

Power words for this topic

sibling
a brother or sister
In a sentenceChildren with siblings learn to share early.
rivalry
competition for the same goal or attention
In a sentenceSibling rivalry can teach negotiation skills.
self-reliance
the ability to depend on oneself
In a sentenceOnly children often develop strong self-reliance.
well-rounded
having a balanced range of abilities and experiences
In a sentenceMany only children grow up perfectly well-rounded.