Band 9 model answer
In certain cultures, it remains common for parents to determine their children's professions. While I acknowledge that parental guidance has value, I firmly disagree that parents should dictate a child's career, because such decisions ought ultimately to rest with the individual who must live them.
The argument for parental choice is not without merit. Parents possess life experience their children lack, and they may foresee which fields offer security, respectable income, and stability. A young person dazzled by a glamorous but precarious ambition might be steered, sensibly, toward a more dependable profession. Furthermore, parents who have invested heavily in their child's education understandably hope to see that investment yield a prosperous future, and their advice often reflects genuine concern.
However, the case against imposing a career is, to my mind, far stronger. A profession occupies the greater part of adult life, and forcing someone into work they neither enjoy nor value is a recipe for chronic dissatisfaction. People perform best in fields that engage their passions and talents, so a career chosen against the grain often results in mediocrity and resentment. Many who are pressured into a parent's preferred path abandon it later, wasting years and straining the family bond in the process.
For these reasons, I believe parents should advise rather than decide. Their proper role is to expose children to options, share hard-won wisdom, and offer support, while leaving the final choice to the young person concerned. A career embraced freely commands far greater commitment than one imposed from above. Guidance, freely given and freely weighed, serves children far better than control.
Examiner’s notes
- Task Response: the 'to what extent' prompt is answered with a strong, clearly stated disagreement, while the opposing view is fairly acknowledged.
- Coherence and Cohesion: the pivot 'However, the case against... is far stronger' marks the writer's stance and balances the concession paragraph effectively.
- Lexical Resource: expressive, idiomatic phrasing such as 'against the grain', 'chronic dissatisfaction' and 'hard-won wisdom' signals a high lexical ceiling.